The Art of the Upsell: How We Came Up With The Recipe To Increase The Bar’s Online Sales

Repeat Purchase Rate

Increased 6%

within the first 30 days post-implementation.

Engagement Rate Boosted by

50%

Customer Retention Improved by

20% 

Website Traffic Up by

30% 

Free strategy call!

THE CLIENT

About The Bar

The Bar is part of the distinguished Diageo family—owners of celebrated brands such as Don Julio and Johnnie Walker. Offering a unique online selection of spirits, cocktail kits, and custom engraving services, The Bar enhances the consumer experience beyond the traditional liquor store visit. In our partnership with them, we focused on overcoming the challenges of online spirits shopping and optimizing The Bar's digital strategy to improve customer engagement and retention. 

Free strategy call!

Accelerating Customer Retention

Customer Retention Improved

20%

Accelerating Customer Retention

The Bar approached us with a straightforward yet challenging objective: significantly increase their repeat purchase rate. Understanding the convenience of in-store alcohol purchases, The Bar faced the inherent challenge of enticing customers to return online post their initial purchase.

From the start, we recognized that timing was crucial: The Bar’s existing strategy of re-engaging customers 30 days post-purchase was not optimizing the potential for quicker repeat sales. Our goal was to devise a method that would not only shorten this window but also make the proposition irresistible at an earlier stage.

What were the pain points?

The Main Challenge: Enhancing Online Sales in a Predominantly Offline Market

The primary hurdle for The Bar was to increase the repeat purchase rate in an industry where consumers typically prefer buying alcohol in-person due to convenience and tradition. This challenge was compounded by the need to make these repeat purchases happen sooner and more frequently, against the backdrop of a highly competitive market where digital presence is still growing.

So we identified key areas of focus:

  • How to Encourage Repeat Purchases Quicker? With initial engagements typically followed by a lengthy 30-day wait before any subsequent marketing touchpoints, there was a clear need to shorten this cycle to maintain customer interest and capitalize on their initial engagement.
  • How to Stand Out in a Saturated Market? The challenge was not just to attract customers but to offer them compelling reasons to choose an online purchase over the convenience of local stores.
  • How to Leverage The Bar's Unique Offerings for Better Engagement? Given The Bar's unique offerings like custom engravings and exclusive cocktail kits, figuring out how to effectively highlight these features online was crucial to converting and retaining online shoppers.

Addressing these things required a strategic overhaul of the existing marketing approaches to foster a quicker and stronger connection with first-time buyers and encourage them to become repeat customers.

Free strategy call!

How did we do it?

We identified the need to reduce the time between first and second purchases to boost repeat business rates significantly. Instead of the typical 30-day wait to re-engage customers, we introduced a strategic change that proved pivotal.

Building on this made the next steps easy:

Quick Engagement Post-Purchase:

Just 7 days after a first purchase, customers now receive a special promotional offer. This change was designed to maintain momentum and interest, potentially engaging customers even before their initial order had arrived.

Special Discount Incentives:

We implemented a unique discount of $15.98 for the first re-purchase. This specific amount was chosen based on our analysis of the promotional responsiveness of our audience, ensuring it was attractive yet sustainable for the business model.

Dynamic Promotional Strategy:

Initially rolled out to first-time purchasers only, this strategy quickly showed signs of success, prompting plans to expand it further. Early data showed a promising increase in repeat purchase rates (RPR), jumping to 6% in the last 30 days—a significant improvement from the previous quarter.

Optimized Timing and Personalization:

Leveraging data-driven insights, we optimized the timing and personalization of our outreach efforts. The goal was to make each communication feel timely and relevant, increasing the likelihood of conversion.

Iterative Testing and Refinement:

Continuous testing and refinement of the promotional offers allowed us to understand better what resonates with our customers. This approach ensured that each iteration was more targeted and effective than the last.

Iterative Testing and Refinement:

Continuous testing and refinement of the promotional offers allowed us to understand better what resonates with our customers. This approach ensured that each iteration was more targeted and effective than the last.

Iterative Testing and Refinement:

Continuous testing and refinement of the promotional offers allowed us to understand better what resonates with our customers. This approach ensured that each iteration was more targeted and effective than the last.

We observed immediate results from these strategic changes, with notable early successes like two new purchases shortly after implementing the new strategy, compared to three in the prior 90 days.

These results have encouraged a broader rollout and have opened discussions on how early engagement strategies might be beneficial across other product lines and brands within our portfolio. 

By redefining our approach to customer engagement, we helped The Bar cut through the competitive noise of the liquor industry, providing compelling reasons for customers to return sooner and engage more deeply with the brand.

Free strategy call!

Account Overview

We Inherited an Account That Had:

  • Limited Direct-to-Consumer (DTC) Engagement
  • Delayed Customer Re-engagement
  • Underutilized Unique Selling Points
  • Generic Marketing Approaches
  • Inadequate Use of Analytics

What We Implemented for The Bar

Accelerated Re-engagement Strategy

We reduced the re-engagement timeline from 30 days to just 7 days post-purchase with a targeted promotional offer, encouraging quicker repeat purchases.

Enhanced Personalization and Targeting:

Leveraged data insights to tailor promotions and communications, focusing on personalization that aligns with customer preferences and buying behavior.

Promotion of Unique Offerings:

Strategically highlighted unique offerings like custom engraving and cocktail kits through targeted marketing campaigns, enhancing the perceived value and distinctiveness of The Bar’s online presence.

Dynamic Promotional Offers:

Introduced a new promotional discount of $15.98 for the first re-purchase to test the responsiveness of customers to different price points and offers.

Comprehensive Data Utilization:

Implemented advanced analytics to continuously monitor customer behavior and campaign performance, allowing for agile adjustments and improved targeting strategies.

Free strategy call!

Main points to note:

Accelerate Customer Re-engagement:

Reduce the time between initial purchase and follow-up marketing. Implement early re-engagement strategies, like sending a promotional offer within 7 days post-purchase, to maintain customer interest and increase repeat purchases.

Enhance Personalization Efforts:

Utilize data-driven insights to tailor promotions and communications specifically to individual customer preferences. Personalization increases the relevance and effectiveness of your marketing efforts, boosting customer satisfaction and conversion rates.

Highlight Unique Selling Propositions (USPs):

Differentiate your online offerings from traditional retail experiences. Promote unique services such as custom engraving or exclusive products through targeted campaigns to enhance the perceived value and appeal of shopping with your brand online.

Implement Dynamic Pricing Strategies:

Test different promotional offers to find the optimal pricing strategy that attracts customers without sacrificing profitability. Use discounts strategically to entice first-time re-purchases and establish a pattern of return visits.

Optimize Digital Touchpoints:

Always improve the user experience on your digital platforms. Streamline navigation, enhance mobile responsiveness, and ensure that all customer interactions are seamless and engaging to support higher conversion rates.

Free strategy call!

The Outcome?

Repeat Purchase Rate

Increased 6%

within the first 30 days post-implementation.

Engagement Rate Boosted by

50%

Customer Retention Improved by

20% 

Website Traffic Up by

30% 

If you’re looking to elevate your brand and achieve long term sustainable growth, we’d love to discuss how our expertise can drive your success. Enter your details below, and let’s start the conversation!